I’m
not generally one to hold grudges, so forgive me if I use this venue to
air my grievances against a certain Astros’ third baseman whose
initials are Morgan Ensberg. You see, about
this time last year, this Ensberg fella was quite the promising
commodity in fantasy baseball circles, and I had my eye on him. There was, after all, reason to look.
Ensberg
had just come off a rather impressive showing in 2003, hitting a solid
.291 with a robust 25 bombs and 60 RBIs – in only 385 at-bats. Throw
in his 69 runs scored, a sexy .907 OPS, and the fact that he was tucked
in a lineup featuring proven fantasy studs like Lance Berkman, Jeff
Kent, Jeff Bagwell, and Craig Biggio, and you can see why I was so high
on Ensberg. Not to mention, he was playing his home games in a park
that’s responsible for more yard work than Martha Stewart in May.
In
short, Ensberg was primed for a monster year, so you might have
imagined my excitement upon acquiring his services in the ninth round
of my March draft. Needless to say, I was ready to reap the rewards of a breakout season waiting to happen.
Three months, 208 at-bats – believe me, I just counted – and
0 (that’s “z-e-r-o”!) home runs later, I knew I’d been had. By July, it
was long past due to say good riddance to Ensberg. Annoyed
for essentially bringing this embarrassment and aggravation upon
myself, I could think of only one thing to say as I disposed of my
Ensberg rubbish: My bad.
Or perhaps more appropriately: My bust. That’s just what
Morgan Ensberg was – a bust. Lucky for me, I’d somehow managed to draft
Aramis Ramirez, too, so I wound up okay at third base in the end. But
that’s not the point. The point is that I’m here to try to prevent
everyone from suffering through a similarly damaging experience.
Well, now that I’ve got that off my chest, here’s a look at some hitters that are primed for Pamela Anderson-sized busts.
Adrian Beltre (3B, SEA): It’s the unofficial Breakout Equation: Notorious Underachiever + Contract Year = Cha-Ching! But
now that Beltre’s broken out and cashed in, don’t expect a repeat of
his ridiculous, dollar-driven .334, 48, 121 performance.
Melvin Mora (3B, BAL): With
so many studs at 3B, let another manager waste a fourth- round pick on
this injury-prone player who, until last year, had failed to reach even
20 homers or 65 RBIs in a season.
Jeff Kent (2B, LA): Second base is a shallow position, meaning someone will overpay for the aging Kent. Let them, because you’re better off taking Mark Loretta or Marcus Giles later, especially since Kent now calls pitcher-friendly Dodger Stadium his home.
David Wright (3B, NYM): Don’t get me wrong: Wright is good. But
buying into the hype and taking him before Round 8 to be your starting
third-sacker this year (based on only half a season) is the equivalent
of drafting Jose Reyes as your starting 2B last year. And we all know how that turned out.
Mike Lowell (3B, FLA):
Here’s a good example of a proven 3B I’d take instead of reaching for
Wright. But what Lowell has proven is that he’s what I call a “Fourth
of July Guy” because that date signals the end of his value. Be sure to
trade him before the fireworks.
Carlos Guillen (SS, DET): There
is a downside to being the biggest fantasy surprise of the previous
season – being atop the list of candidates for biggest bust this time
around.
J.D. Drew (OF, LA): Funny how a contract
year can motivate an injury-riddled player to reach 500 ABs for the
first time in his career. If that’s not suspicious enough for you, how
about this: Drew still hasn’t reached the 100-RBIs plateau.
Mike Piazza (C, NYM): Here’s another unofficial formula: Accomplished Athlete + Famous Girl = Career Suicide (think: Tiger, Andre, Nomar). The
fact that Piazza just married ex-Playmate and Baywatch actress Alicia
Rickter – and the fact that he hasn’t accomplished much the past two
years to begin with – should turn you off.
Paul Konerko (1B, CWS): Don’t
let last year’s 41 homers and 117 RBIs lead you on – Konerko (.280, 27,
93 in six full seasons) is more Sean Casey (.305, 17, 83) than you
think. And that includes Casey’s awful 2002: .261, 6, 42.
Michael Young (SS, TEX): Young won’t be a total bust. Just expect stats closer to 2003 (.306, 14, 72) than 2004 (.313, 22, 99), and draft accordingly.
Vinny Castilla (3B, WSH): Last year’s NL RBIs leader with 131 – yeah, you read that right – leaves the cozy confines of Colorado. That means you leave him off your roster.
Jose Guillen (OF, WSH): You need a head case like Guillen on your team like you need a hole in your head – and your lineup.
Jimmy Rollins (SS, PHI): Think
2005’s Edgar Renteria: a solid player at a shallow SS position whose
overrated career year catapults him into an unjustifiably high draft
spot, thus resulting in widespread disappointment among his owners upon
outrageously overpaying for a season more in line with his career
numbers.
Remember, if you do your homework and keep this list in mind, you just might avoid being “Ensberg-ed” on draft day.
Next week: pitcher busts.
Email comments, suggestions, advice, information, and hate-mail to JayCat11@aol.com